Siemens Healthineers, a subsidiary 75% owned by Siemens AG, has filed a legal complaint against its supplier, WSS, over issues arising from a $40 million contract with the Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) for CT scanners. The medtech company alleges that WSS’s failure to fulfill contractual obligations has led to increased costs and impacted its ability to supply the DLA effectively.
According to Siemens Healthineers, the dispute has resulted in various forms of damages, including delayed payments to the DLA and additional costs incurred from engaging a replacement integrator. The company also claims to have incurred repair costs for government-issued shelters provided to WSS for testing, which were reportedly returned in a damaged state.
The conflict between Siemens Healthineers and WSS began shortly after the DLA selected them for the contract, with Siemens acting as the prime contractor. In mid-June 2019, Siemens issued a purchase order to WSS worth nearly $370,000, with an expected delivery to the DLA by September 25 of the same year. However, WSS’s projected timeline indicated a completion date in mid-October, prompting Siemens to renegotiate with the DLA.
Subsequently, the two companies engaged in disagreements over the financial aspects of the contract. WSS eventually ceased all integration work in January, leading Siemens to terminate the contract in March 2020 on grounds of default.
Siemens Healthineers subsequently contracted another company for the integrations, albeit at higher prices, stating it had no alternative to avoid defaulting on its government contract.
This lawsuit adds to the complexities of defense procurement, where prime contractors like Siemens Healthineers face strict compliance requirements. This case mirrors a similar dispute where Lockheed Martin sued Howmet Aerospace over supply issues for the F-35 stealth military jet. In the Lockheed Martin case, a judge issued a temporary order to ensure continued supply, highlighting the critical nature of these defense-related contracts.